Create Your Own Marching Shows

Latest Posts

Main Forums

MML Discussion Design Help MML Questions

Sub-Forums

Show Design Band & Corps Music Writing Competitions

Feedback

Suggestion Box Report a Bug

What's Up

Joe's Work Log Announcements

Follow Us

Facebook Twitter

Critique for Phillup11

Phillup11 Mar '10
Tell me what you think and what to fix.

This one doesn't really have a theme. I'm just trying to make a Realistic High School level show. not DCI lol. :) So tell me what you think and what i should fix to get the best score possible.

micromarching.com/preview/phillup11
fernandp Mar '10
I really like the drill, i think it flows well. I would make more of an impact with the guard. I know it still needs many sets left but a strong flag feature would make it cool, in my opinion.
Justin Ekstrom Mar '10
At the beginning, I don't like how you pulled the lines apart, only to put them immediately back together. It messed up the flow. Everything past that looks nice.
Bryan LaHaise Mar '10
This is a fabulous show so far, what I would do, is add some flag work, with differant shades of blue in the flag's, to go with the uniform's maybe with each toss, have them come down a differant color or some two tone blue in the flag color to go with the uniform's. I love what I see in the show and drill work so far.
Phillup11 Mar '10
Thanks for the critique. I will look into adding Flags to the CG the last closing chunk of the drill. As for the comment from Justin, i'm not sure if i can fix that since its at the beginning, but i'll see what i can do. :)
DocMcFluhry Mar '10
I get what Mr. Ekstrom is saying though. It just seems a little repetitive. Like pulling them apart and then putting them back together stunted the fluidity just a bit.
Phillup11 Mar '10
I just changed the first set to make it look a little better hopefully. I hope that removed that repetitive look. Tell me what you think. And i'll see if i keep it.
blakep Mar '10
The transition from the opening set, to the first set, the baritones, they go straight up really fast. I think its sloppy and it caught my eye really quick. The fluidity is okay.
Dementieva Mar '10
loved it~
Phillup11 Mar '10
True blakep. Yea, that was to fix a problem that was mentioned earlier. I'll see if i can find another way.

Thanks Dementieva :)

Log in to add a comment.